Diamonds and Gold and Festival Foods present Let Me Be Frank Productions’ all-new comedy musical, “Menoma Mia – Here We Go Again,” July 22nd through August 20th at the Meyer Theatre.

In 2021, Let Me Be Frank Productions shared “Menoma Mia,” – an all-original show centered around an annual karaoke contest at Sheridan Lanes in Menominee, MI. Sarah Sheridan invited three mystery men, who all had been a part of her mother’s life in one way or another, back to the annual karaoke contest to see if she could figure out which one was dear old dad. This year, we share a prequel of sorts in “Menoma Mia – Here We Go Again.” Now expecting a child of her own, Sarah finds her mom’s diary and discovers what truly happened the night her mom and dad made a love connection. We go back to the very first Sheridan Lanes Karaoke Contest, where Amy Sheridan meets three potential suitors — Frank the FIB, Pat the Yooper, and Tom the ex-con. Amy’s best friend Lisa is by her side for moral (or perhaps, not-so-moral…) support, and her little brother, Harrison, is there to annoy big sis with a quick comeback. Join us on a journey with Sarah as she learns about the fateful night that changed Amy’s life forever!

“Menoma Mia – Here We Go Again” opens Friday, July 22nd, with a benefit show for the Capitol Civic Centre Act Two project. For the opening night performance of “Menoma Mia – Here We Go Again,” $10 of every sold ticket goes to this valuable organization in N. E. WI.

“Menoma Mia — Here We Go Again” then runs:

Saturday, July 23rd at 7:30pm

Thursday, July 28th at 7:30pm

Friday, July 29th at 7:30pm

Saturday, July 30th at 7:30pm

Thursday, August 4th at 7:30pm

Friday, August 5th at 7:30pm

Saturday, August 6th at 7:30pm

Thursday, August 11th at 7:30pm

Friday, August 12th at 7:30pm

Saturday, August 13th at 7:30pm

Thursday, August 18th at 1:00pm and 7:30pm

Friday, August 19th at 7:30pm

Saturday, August 20th at 1:00pm and 7:30pm

Tickets are available at,, by calling Ticketstar at 920-494-3401, or at the door (the Meyer Theatre box office opens one hour before each performance).

An out-of-town performance will be held at the Capitol Civic Centre in Manitowoc on Wednesday, July 27th, at 7:00pm. Head to or call 920-683-2184 for tickets and more information.

Cast:  Frank Hermans, Pat Hibbard, Tom Verbrick, Amy Riemer, Lisa Borley, Sarah Galati, and Harrison Hermans

Band: Dennis Panneck (guitar), Pat Hibbard (bass), Tony Pilz (keyboards), Andrew Klaus (drums).

Lights: Ross Loining

Sound: Kelly Klaus

Song selections:

Super Trouper – ABBA

Knowing Me, Knowing You – ABBA

One Of Us – ABBA

I’ve Been Waiting For You – ABBA

Waterloo – ABBA

Honey, Honey – ABBA


Thank You For The Music – ABBA

Money, Money, Money – ABBA

Voulez-Vous – ABBA

I Have A Dream – ABBA

Fernando – ABBA

Dancin’ Fool – Frank Zappa

Folsom Prison Blues – Johnny Cash

Jamie’s Cryin’ – Van Halen

Joanne -Michael Nesmith

Always – Atlantic Starr

Keep it Comin’ Love – KC & The Sunshine Band

Mississippi Queen – Mountain

Rocket Man – Elton John

Heartbeat It’s A Love Beat – The DeFranco Family

Dancin Queen – ABBA

<< Back

More Info / Buy Tickets
Gift Certificates Link